The Shay’s Rebellion was not justified because the government at the time was legitimately trying to negotiate with the rebels in good faith. The government was also working within the bounds of the law and had not done anything to deserve such treatment.
Furthermore, the rebellion showed a lack of understanding of the philosophy of the Form of the Good, which holds that there can be no perfect society without a strong central government. Finally, the violence and destruction caused by the rebellion only serve to harm innocent people and damage property, rather than furthering any sort of meaningful political or social goal.
The government taxes them, their families are poor, and they have no choice but to pay. They claim that because their voices were not heard, they had no other option except to rise up in rebellion. Did they really have no alternative but to resort to violence in order to attract the attention of the authorities? No, they did not. There was a cause for the government’s behavior of disregarding.
The people were not thinking about the good of the community, but only about themselves and what they wanted. They were not thinking about the form of the good, which is what the government was trying to do. The government was trying to establish a society in which people could live together in harmony, with each person contributing to the common good. The rebels were not interested in that; they just wanted their own way.
The answer to solving their problems was not violence, but negotiation. The government was willing to negotiate with them, but they refused. They would rather resort to violence and try to force their demands on the government, instead of sitting down and talking it out like civilized human beings. That is why Shay’s Rebellion was not justified. The rebels were not thinking about the good of the community; they were only thinking about themselves.
First, let’s look at the options available to the rebels before they revolted. They might have worked with the authorities to increase the economy rather than pushing them to do more for settlers and farmers. My friends, taxes were designed to benefit the colonists themselves.
The government needed to find a way to get more money so that they could support the colonies better. The farmers and other colonists did not want to help because they wanted everything for free. They thought that the government should do everything for them and that they should not have to pay anything. This is not how it works my friends. We all have to contribute to society in order for it to function properly. If everyone just takes and doesn’t give, then the system falls apart.
The farmers also could have tried negotiating with the government instead of rebelling. They could have come up with a compromise that would work for both sides. But no, they decided to take matters into their own hands and start a rebellion. This was not the answer. All it did was cause more problems and violence.
To not realize this and put their lives in danger was unjustified; people even perished in the uprising. The taxes were also distinct from the British ones, which were paid to cover a debt and for pleasures for the king. After the rebellion, the government did take action. It’s just that they believed they’d found a solution by imposing taxes on the greatest of society; it wasn’t misused in any way.
The Articles of Confederation were made to be improved, not just thrown out because of one rebellion. Shay’s Rebellion was not justified and it would have been better if they tried to negotiate or take another approach to fixing the problems instead.
The government is a necessary evil according to some philosophers like Plato. In his work The Republic, he talks about the form of the Good and how everything in the world is a shadow of that Good. He also talks about how there are three classes in society and how the philosopher-kings should rule because they have knowledge of the Good.
Although this is just a theory, it can be applied to real life and how we view our government. We elect officials to represent us and make decisions that we may not agree with, but we do so because we hope that they have the best interests of the people at heart.
The government taxes us to raise revenue for necessary expenses like defense and infrastructure. We may not always agree with how they spend our money, but we trust that they are doing so in a way that will benefit the most people. In some cases, negotiations can be made to reach a compromise that is acceptable to both sides. However, there are times when negotiation is not possible or desirable, and conflict arises.
Shay’s Rebellion was one such conflict. The rebels were angry about the tax burden placed on them by the government and felt that their voices were not being heard. They took up arms and attempted to overthrow the government, but they were ultimately unsuccessful. While their actions may have been motivated by good intentions, they were not justified in taking such drastic measures.
The government did take action after the rebellion. They revised the Articles of Confederation and implemented the Constitution, which addressed some of the concerns of the rebels. However, the Constitution did not solve all of the problems that led to the rebellion, and conflict continues to this day.
Shay’s Rebellion was not justified, but it was a reminder that our government is not perfect and that we must be vigilant in ensuring that our voices are heard. We must work together to find solutions to our problems so that we can create a more just and peaceful society for all.
The government may have been attempting to convey that the colonists must work to improve their standard of living by ignoring the peaceful discussions. They had very little money to start with. The government was not ignoring the colonists’ complaints, since they were rebelling and claiming that the taxes were excessive. They believed that paying taxes is a necessary component in order to achieve a bright future for themselves.
Shay’s Rebellion was not justified. The government did not have to be as harsh as they were, but the colonists also need to remember that the government is trying to help them in the long term.not applications from rebels like Shay.